Back when I was a younger man I would go all in to collecting a big summer event. Anything with that event's banner on it was mine, this obviously meant that I often picked up tie-ins with little or no bearing on the event itself (The disassembled tie ins were bad for this, and I still haven't really forgiven anyone for Civil War - X Men.)
Anyway I'm older now and with a baby on the way, is I decided that I would minimise the impact of this event by following these rules
1. Unless you'd have picked up any new titles, don't, aside from the SI main
2. Don't buy every tie in with a Secret invasion banner
3. Don't buy an X book, you know it will barely tie in
4. Double for Wolverine.
Now some would say I violated Rule 1 picking up Captain Britain and MI13, but I disagree, while I am reducing my comics load a Paul Cornell written series featuring British Super heroes is right up my street. However I have been undone, and it was the Jade Giantess She-Hulk that was my undoing, Its always the green chicks isn't it.
The latest run of She-hulk has been pretty good, and since her sidekick Jazinda is a skrull I was looking forward to her tie in (I pick up the title anyway so no harm done) but Peter David also writes X-Factor, and while I hear its pretty good I direct you to rule 3. Only I have had to break it because the SI tie in is spread across 2 issues of X factor and 1 of She-Hulk.
like I said, Damn.
SO, brief impressions based on Parts 1 & 2 of "He Loves you" Story wise, its not too bad, Shulkie and Jazinda are looking for a skrull that tends to precede invasion, X-Factor are looking for a mutant called Darwin, little do they know that the two are hanging out together, wires are crossed and super hero fights ensue. The X-Factor issues suffered in two ways, first, for a crossover it wasn't very noob friendly, I was left a bit confused as to who was who, this wasn't helped by some god awful art. The She-Hulk issue was better, but I will have to sit through more of the terrible art to get a conclusion. Plus I know I failed.
I have a dislike for that sort of tie in, you know, the one where a story is carried across several different and often unassociated titles. Mainly because it causes me to fork out more cash. I'm also suspicious that I am being used to prop up an ailing title (Although with my general taste in comics the title i read is usually the ailing one)
:squee:
16 years ago
That does sound pretty horrible. Its one thing when related titles crossover. Its forgivable if Green Lantern starts a story that continues in Green Lantern Corps for example (or Iron Man leads into War Machine).
ReplyDeleteBut crossing over stuff with a random X-book does indeed have the vague whiff of helping out an ailing title. I don't follow Marvel sales figures, so I've got no idea if that is actually the case, but I know if I was buying She-Hulk, I'd be knarked off.
As I am, the only thing the books have in common is the writer (Peter david) and much as I like the guys work I'd have told him "Use She ulk in the X-Factor book or Use X-Factor in the she-Hulk book, but none of this story running through several titles.
ReplyDeleteAgree that it works in linked titles (New and Mighty Avengers, or even the Initiative) and its even forgivable if it is say Iron Man into Mighty Avengers (He is in both teams)
Although that did get me into buying Deadpool in the last run, it crossed over with balck panther and I bought soem extra issues because it promised to reveal Titania's secret (And it wasn't "She's a Dude" like everyone in the book suspected)
In fact, the best example I can think of for "acceptable title crossover" is the old Hands of the Mandarin crossover.
ReplyDeleteAnd even then I just skipped the Iron Man issue, rather than buy War Machine and Force Works.
Ah the glorious days when I didn't religously pick up crossovers. I had money then.
Hands of the mandarin was great, although the crossover lasted outside the branded issues you coudl quite happily read whichever titles main issues without getting too lost, of course there was the Iron man vs War machine prelude and the Iron man post issue but relaly it ran well as contained issues or as a big crossover story
ReplyDelete